Betrayal at House on the Hill

You explore a creepy haunted mansion tile by tile until a terrifying scenario begins. One of the players turns against the rest of the group based on the items you found. The story changes every time making it a fun narrative experience. It takes a few rounds to really understand the mechanics, but after that, it flows nicely. You will want to play it a few times to try different strategies. I usually bring this out when we have a group that wants something engaging but not overly complicated. The components are well made and hold up to frequent use. It is a reliable option for a game night when people are tired of the usual stuff. Make sure you have a decent sized table to set everything up properly.